Payroll Specialist
Creative Financial Staffing
Plymouth, IN · Posted October 20, 2026
More in Indiana job market · Finance jobs
Pay compared with the market
This listing does not state pay. Across 156 open payroll specialist listings that state pay, the middle half runs $54,500 to $74,500 and the median is $65,000.
Listed pay is what employers advertise, not what people are paid.
About the job
PAYROLL SPECIALIST | Plymouth, IN
About the Company & Opportunity
• A reputable and growing Plymouth, IN organization is seeking a dependable Payroll Specialist to manage multi-state payroll processing and support related HR and accounting functions. • This Payroll Specialist will ensure accurate and timely payroll administration, tax compliance, and employee record maintenance. • The company offers a welcoming, team-focused environment with strong leadership and a commitment to work-life balance. • Perfect for someone who thrives on accuracy, deadlines, and confidential work in a supportive and structured setting.
Why This Opportunity Stands Out
Stable Local Employer – Join a trusted Plymouth company that values consistency, collaboration, and attention to detail. Ownership of Payroll Function – The Payroll Specialist will oversee end-to-end payroll processing for hourly and salaried employees. Cross-Functional Exposure – Collaborate with HR and accounting teams on employee data, benefit deductions, and reporting. Room for Growth – Opportunity to expand responsibilities in HRIS, compliance, or benefits administration as skills develop.
Key Responsibilities
• Process biweekly and weekly payroll cycles accurately and on schedule. • Review timesheets, verify hours, and reconcile discrepancies. • Maintain employee payroll records and update pay changes, tax withholdings, and benefits. • Prepare and file payroll tax reports and ensure compliance with local, state, and federal regulations. • Assist with audits, 401(k) contributions, and year-end W-2 preparation. • Respond to payroll-related inquiries with professionalism and discretion.
Core Competencies
• 3+ years of payroll processing experience (multi-state preferred). • Proficiency in ADP, Paylocity, Paycor, or similar payroll systems. • Strong understanding of payroll laws, taxes, and wage garnishments. • High attention to detail, confidentiality, and time management. • Excellent communication and problem-solving skills.
Location: Plymouth, IN (Eastern Time Zone) Schedule: Full-time, Monday–Friday Compensation: $48,000–$60,000 annually based on experience
Click here to apply online
EB-1478346630