Insurance Defense Paralegal
State Farm
Jericho, NY · Posted October 22, 2026
Just laid off? Start here: a plan for the first weeks
See every open role at State Farm
More in New York job market · Agriculture & Food Production · Legal jobs
More roles at State Farm
- Lead Software Engineer · Bloomington, IL
- Marketing Lifecycle Analyst · Bloomington, IL
- Legal Secretary · Summit, NJ
- Trial Attorney - Insurance Defense · Concord, CA
- Attorney · Chicago, IL
- Attorney · Indianapolis, IN
Similar jobs
- Workers' Compensation Attorney · Morgan & Morgan · Brooklyn, NY
- Personal Injury Paralegal Growth, Competitive Pay & Benefits · Bush & Bush Law Group · New York, NY
- Paralegal · Starwood Hotels & Resorts · New York, NY
- Commerical RE Paralegal · Herbert Smith Freehills Kramer · New York, NY
- Paralegal · Start My Business · New York, NY
- Personal Injury Paralegal (Plaintiff, 3+ years’ experience) · Brach Eichler · New York, NY
Legal jobs in the rankings
Rankings about legal jobs
- Best cities for legal jobs #1 New York (854 openings)
- Best cities for legal pay after cost of living #1 San Mateo ($238k)
- Most requested AI skills in legal jobs #1 AI tools in daily work (3.9%)
- Employers with the most legal jobs #1 Morgan & Morgan (195 roles)
Skills this job asks for
Say which you have and which you want to build. We use it to match you to jobs like this one.
About the job
Overview
Being good neighbors – helping people, investing in our communities, and making the world a better place – is who we are at State Farm. It is at the core of how we operate and the reason for our success. We're moving with urgency to become a Next Gen Good Neighbor, with technology that strengthens human connections and enhances the customer experience. As an employee, you'll spend less time navigating systems and more time applying judgment, empathy, and expertise in the moments that matter most.
Grow Your Skills, Grow Your Potential
Responsibilities
James F. Butler & Associates, insurance staff counsel for State Farm Insurance Companies, is seeking a Paralegal to join the Jericho, NY Claim Litigation office. While every day can provide different experiences and opportunities, a Paralegal supports attorneys with drafting, serving, and responding to discovery, pleadings and pre-trial motions, as well as trial preparation for first and third party insurance defense/bodily injury cases. The office allows for collaborative environments with experienced peer mentors. There are no billable hours in this opportunity. This role provides diversity of work and the opportunity for career development. This role will interact with clients, experts, and witnesses throughout the litigation process. The position is classified as a hybrid role, meaning that the work arrangement calls for hours in the office and virtually. Everyone in a hybrid role is required to spend time in the office. Work arrangements could change over time based on business needs. Hours for the position are Monday-Friday, 8:30 AM to 5:00 PM or 9:00 AM to 5:30 PM.
Location: 300 Jericho Quadrangle, Jericho, New York 11753
Responsibilities include, but are not limited to
Assist attorneys in discovery and pre-trial matters under attorney supervision
Assist attorneys in handling assigned case files and delivering other legal services under attorney supervision
Prepare cases for court appearances, depositions, and trial including contacting experts and clients
Draft motions, pleadings, litigation reports and medical summaries
Qualifications
Please only apply for this position if you meet the minimum requirements.
Previous experience required:
1-7 of years of recent civil litigation experience, preferably insurance defense or bodily injury environment
Background in drafting discovery responses and trial preparation
Ability to draft pleadings, routine motions, legal memoranda, litigation reports and medical summaries
Familiarity with New York Civil Court Rules and Procedures
Knowledge medical terminology and records
Key Skills required
Strong organizational skills, ability to work independently, prioritize workload, multi-task in a fast-paced environment, and communicate effectively
Strong written communication skills, attention to detail
Legal research
Technology/software experience required
Strong software/technical skills
Working knowledge of a Case Management system
Working Knowledge of a Document Storage system
Education requirements including licensing and certifications
Prior litigation or paralegal experience, paralegal degree/certificate/certification, medical training, or relevant coursework or legal studies degree is required
Additional Details
Applicants are required to be eligible to lawfully work in the U.S. immediately. State Farm will not sponsor applicants for U.S. work opportunities.
Our Benefits
Because work-life balance is a priority at State Farm, compensation is based on our standard 38:45-hour work week!
Potential starting salary range: $70,525 - $89,637.50
Starting salary will be based on skills, background, and experience
High end of the range limited to applicants with significant relevant experience
Potential yearly incentive pay up to 15% of base salary
At State Farm, we offer more than just a paycheck. Check out our suite of benefits designed to give you the flexibility you need to take care of you and your family!
Get Paid! On top of our competitive pay, you are eligible for an annual raise and bonus.
Stay Well! Focus on you and your family’s health with our robust health and wellbeing programs. State Farm pays most of your healthcare premium, and we offer multiple healthcare plan options, including a high deductible plan. All medical plans provide 100% coverage for in-network preventative care, AND you and your family have access to vision, dental, telemedicine, 24/7 mental health professionals, and much more!
Develop and Grow! Take advantage of educational benefits like industry leading training programs, top-notch tuition assistance programs, employee resource groups, and mentoring.
Plan Ahead! Plan for those big moments in life with benefits like fertility/IVF/adoption assistance, college coaching, national discount programs, interactive monthly financial workshops, free financial coaching, and more. You can also start a savings account or consider financing through our State Farm Federal Credit Union!
Take a Little “You” Time! You will have access to our generous time off policies designed so you can plan around holidays, family events, volunteering, or just to take a relaxing day off. With the opportunity to initially earn up to 20 days annually plus parental leave, paid holidays, celebration day, life leave (40 hours/year), bereavement leave, and community service/education support days, there will be plenty of time for you!
Give Back! We offer several ways to give back through our Matching Gift Program, Good Neighbor Grant Program, and the Employee Assistance Fund.
Finish Strong! Plan for retirement using free financial advisors and a 401(k) plan with company contributions of up to 7% of your salary.
Visit our State Farm Careers page for more information on our benefits , locations , and the hiring process of joining the State Farm team!
LI-AP3
James F. Butler & Associates, insurance staff counsel for State Farm Insurance Companies, is seeking a Paralegal to join the Jericho, NY Claim Litigation office. While every day can provide different experiences and opportunities, a Paralegal supports attorneys with drafting, serving, and responding to discovery, pleadings and pre-trial motions, as well as trial preparation for first and third party insurance defense/bodily injury cases. The office allows for collaborative environments with experienced peer mentors. There are no billable hours in this opportunity. This role provides diversity of work and the opportunity for career development. This role will interact with clients, experts, and witnesses throughout the litigation process. The position is classified as a hybrid role, meaning that the work arrangement calls for hours in the office and virtually. Everyone in a hybrid role is required to spend time in the office. Work arrangements could change over time based on business needs. Hours for the position are Monday-Friday, 8:30 AM to 5:00 PM or 9:00 AM to 5:30 PM.
Location: 300 Jericho Quadrangle, Jericho, New York 11753
Responsibilities include, but are not limited to
Assist attorneys in discovery and pre-trial matters under attorney supervision
Assist attorneys in handling assigned case files and delivering other legal services under attorney supervision
Prepare cases for court appearances, depositions, and trial including contacting experts and clients
Draft motions, pleadings, litigation reports and medical summaries
Please only apply for this position if you meet the minimum requirements.
Previous experience required:
1-7 of years of recent civil litigation experience, preferably insurance defense or bodily injury environment
Background in drafting discovery responses and trial preparation
Ability to draft pleadings, routine motions, legal memoranda, litigation reports and medical summaries
Familiarity with New York Civil Court Rules and Procedures
Knowledge medical terminology and records
Key Skills required
Strong organizational skills, ability to work independently, prioritize workload, multi-task in a fast-paced environment, and communicate effectively
Strong written communication skills, attention to detail
Legal research
Technology/software experience required
Strong software/technical skills
Working knowledge of a Case Management system
Working Knowledge of a Document Storage system
Education requirements including licensing and certifications
Prior litigation or paralegal experience, paralegal degree/certificate/certification, medical training, or relevant coursework or legal studies degree is required
Additional Details
Applicants are required to be eligible to lawfully work in the U.S. immediately. State Farm will not sponsor applicants for U.S. work opportunities.