Analyst I, Insurance Compliance
Arbor Realty Trust
Buffalo, NY · Posted November 3, 2026
Just laid off? Start here: a plan for the first weeks
See every open role at Arbor Realty Trust
More in New York job market · Construction & Real Estate · Legal jobs
More roles at Arbor Realty Trust
- AVP, Risk Management · Miami, FL
- Asset Manager · Dallas, TX
- Senior Special Servicing Asset Manager · Buffalo, NY
- Senior Software Engineer · Uniondale, NY
- IT Infrastructure Engineer
- Director, REO Asset Management · Miami, FL
Similar jobs
- Senior Specialist, Trade Compliance · L3HARRIS Technologies · Rochester, NY
- Senior Corporate Compliance Specialist · Constellation Brands · Rochester, NY
- Sr Compliance Analyst · Paychex · Rochester, NY
- Sr Compliance Analyst - Privacy · Paychex · Rochester, NY
- Compliance Auditor Analyst · Upstate Medical University · Syracuse, NY
- IT Compliance Analyst · Intercontinental Exchange · New York, NY
Where Buffalo, NY ranks
Where Buffalo, NY placed in our monthly rankings, month by month. Each month stays online at its own address.
November 2026
- #8Best cities for junior jobs in New York29% · of 11
- #10Best cities for software and engineering jobs in the Northeast121 openings · of 52
- #10Best all-round cities for new graduates in the Northeast51 / 100 · of 26
- #13Cities with the most jobs that do not need a four-year degree in the Northeast44 jobs · of 36
- #13Best cities for mid-career professionals in the Northeast54% · of 70
- #13Best all-round cities for mid-career professionals in the Northeast50 / 100 · of 26
Rankings about legal jobs
- Best cities for legal jobs #1 New York (854 openings)
- Best cities for legal pay after cost of living #1 San Mateo ($238k)
- Most requested AI skills in legal jobs #1 AI tools in daily work (3.9%)
- Employers with the most legal jobs #1 Morgan & Morgan (195 roles)
How AI is used in this kind of work
Among compliance officers, AI is already used for some of the tasks. Measured exposure for compliance officers: 12% (some).
Share of this job’s tasks that AI is already used for at work, from real usage. It is not a forecast of job loss, and a low number means no use seen yet. Source: Anthropic Economic Index.
About the job
Analyst I, Insurance Compliance
Location: Tonawanda, NY (Hybrid)
About the Role
The Analyst, Insurance Compliance, is responsible for ensuring all required insurance coverage(s) are in place at appropriate limits to demonstrate compliance with investor requirements. This position focuses on the efficient review of commercial insurance policies, effectively communicating exceptions to agents and borrowers, and working collaboratively to resolve issues promptly.
What You'll Do
Serve as a point of contact for insurance related questions from clients, insurance agencies, brokers and internal contacts and proficiently explain insurance coverage requirements.
Identify and communicate insurance related issues and trends and develop working knowledge of all investor insurance guidelines and recommendations by phone and email.
Review Loan Agreements, Appraisals, Engineering, Seismic, and Environmental reports to determine loan-specific information relative to insurance requirements.
Perform annual review of insurance coverages by reviewing policies including all schedules and endorsements, invoices, and/or declaration pages and certificates to determine compliance.
Ensure timely follow up occurs on all assigned accounts to ensure expedient resolution of all identified exceptions.
Drafting and filing insurance waivers/variance requests with supporting documentation on non-compliant insurance issues.
Communicate with all applicable parties regarding any lender placed insurance issues and process application for lender placement of insurance where necessary.
Responsible for updating and maintaining all insurance information and documentation within Arbor servicing systems.
Assist with insurance related reporting to investors and auditors.
Assist Portfolio Management team at Arbor with the handling of claims issues as needed (including requesting loss runs and obtaining loss adjustor information.
Meets weekly productivity goals and standards as outlined by their direct supervisor.
Maintains a minimum internal accuracy score of 95% on all assigned reviews.
Process and review insurance endorsements and notices of cancellation and non-renewal.
Process and review insurance for loans involved in securitizations and loan sales.
Communicate with borrowers, agents, and portfolio management in a clear, consistent manner on insurance related issues.
What We're Looking For
Education: High school diploma or equivalent; Associates’ or Bachelor’s degree in Business, Finance, or a related discipline, or equivalent work experience preferred
Experience: Prior experience in commercial insurance or a related commercial servicing environment is preferred, but not required.
Ability to quickly learn and apply detailed guidelines and policy language through training - demonstrated by experience working with complex rules, requirements, contracts, compliance standards, or technical documentation in prior roles
Strong learning agility, with the ability to ask thoughtful questions, absorb feedback, and consistently apply guidance
Clear, professional written and verbal communication skills, with the confidence to engage with both internal and external stakeholders
Strong attention to detail and follow-through, particularly when managing exceptions, deadlines, and documentation
Comfort working in a fast-paced, deadline-driven environment with a strong sense of urgency
Demonstrated critical thinking skills and a solution-oriented mindset
Intermediate Microsoft Office skills
Commercial insurance experience is preferred, but not required. We're seeking motivated candidates with strong aptitude, critical thinking skills, and a willingness to learn. Training and support will be provided.
Arbor Realty Trust, Inc. offers a competitive base salary and discretionary bonus. The starting base salary range for this position is $60,000 to $65,000. The specific compensation that will be offered is based on an understanding of the hired candidates' qualifications at the time of hire. Employees are eligible for a discretionary bonus based on employee work performance reviewed during the course of the year. The total compensation package for this position will also include other elements, a full range of medical, and/or other benefits including 401(k) eligibility and paid time off benefits.
We are proud to be an equal opportunity employer and are committed to maintaining a diverse workforce and an inclusive work environment for our associates, customers and business partners. We do not discriminate on the basis of race, religion, color, national origin, gender, sexual orientation, age, marital status, veteran status, disability, ethnicity, pregnancy or any other legally protected status. We are committed to working with and providing reasonable accommodations to individuals with disabilities.