← Search all jobs

Senior Payroll and Tax Analyst- 3704251

AMS Legal Staffing

New York City, NY · Posted November 2, 2026

Just laid off? Start here: a plan for the first weeks

See every open role at AMS Legal Staffing

More in New York job market · Professional Services & Consulting · Finance jobs

Similar jobs

Where New York City, NY ranks

Where New York City, NY placed in our monthly rankings, month by month. Each month stays online at its own address.

November 2026

How AI is used in this kind of work

AI use among tax examiners and collectors, and revenue agents is little observed so far. Measured exposure for tax examiners and collectors, and revenue agents: 3% (little observed).

Share of this job’s tasks that AI is already used for at work, from real usage. It is not a forecast of job loss, and a low number means no use seen yet. Source: Anthropic Economic Index.

Check how this applies to your own job

Skills this job asks for

Say which you have and which you want to build. We use it to match you to jobs like this one.

  • Excel
  • Audit

About the job

Job Title: Senior Payroll and Tax Analyst

Location: New York, NY 10019

Salary/Payrate: $110K to $130K

Work Environment: Hybrid (#1 of days WFH) / Remote

Term: Fulltime

Bachelor’s degree required: No

Referral Fee: AMS will pay $500 should the person you refer gets

hired

Job Description:

Our client, an international, AmLaw 100 firm, is looking to hire

a Senior Payroll and Tax Analyst at their offices in New York

City. The position will allow for a hybrid work schedule with 4

days a week onsite, 1 remote, and will pay an annual base salary

of $110K to $130K plus a performance-based bonus and

comprehensive benefits package.

The Senior Payroll and Tax Analyst plays a key role in the

accurate, timely processing of our client’s semi-monthly payroll.

The Analyst enters and reviews payroll, with a focus on new hire

and departure calculations, benefit deductions, and other

adjustments. Working with HR, Benefits, and Accounting, the

Analyst validates payroll data, prepares benefits

reconciliations, and supports the proper recording of payroll

transactions. The Analyst also brings strong knowledge of

multi-state payroll taxation and collaborates with the Tax team

on compliance, reporting, and analysis.

Key Responsibilities

* Review and audit new hire and departure calculations for

accuracy, and communicate and resolve discrepancies promptly.

* Partner with Legal personnel and the Benefits department to

reconcile and validate deductions for programs such as

TransitChek, WageWorks, and health club memberships.

* Reconcile 401(k) deductions quarterly to ensure no employee

exceeds the annual contribution limit.

* Process off-cycle payments and retroactive corrections.

* Administer wage garnishments, child support orders, tax levies,

and other court-ordered withholdings.

* Support internal and external audits, including NYS audit,

401(k) plan audits, by providing payroll documentation,

reconciliations, and responses to auditor inquiries.

* Ensure compliance with federal, state, and local payroll tax

and wage-hour regulations.

* Manage multi-state payroll tax withholding and registrations,

including employees who live in one state and work in another,

remote and hybrid workers, and state reciprocity agreements.

* Monitor employee work locations and address changes to confirm

the correct state and local taxes are withheld, and correct any

misapplied withholding.

* Reconcile quarterly tax filings (such as Form 941 and state and

local returns) to payroll records.

* Respond to payroll tax notices and agency inquiries, and

coordinate with the Tax team on resolution.

* Assist with quarterly payroll processing and related ADP

uploads.

* Provide reconciliations and supporting documentation to the

Accounting team to ensure payroll journal entries are complete

and properly recorded in the general ledger.

* Respond promptly to employee payroll inquiries and ensure

errors are corrected in a timely manner.

* Identify and implement process improvements and automation

opportunities.

* Create and run recurring and ad hoc reports in ADP and Excel to

support reconciliations, audits, management reporting, and

requests from Accounting, Tax, and HR.

* Assist with year-end payroll processing and W-2 preparation for

domestic and expatriate payrolls, including reconciling year-end

payroll registers, tax liabilities, and Form 941 and state and

local filings to the general ledger, and resolving variances

before W-2 finalization.

Qualifications

Skills and Competencies

* Strong analytical and problem-solving abilities

* Solid background in payroll processes and payroll taxation

* Extensive experience with ADP Enterprise, including ADP

reporting tools

* Excellent organizational skills and exceptional attention to

detail

* Strong written and verbal communication skills

* Proficiency in Microsoft Excel

Education and Experience

* 8+ years of experience in a payroll or accounting department,

preferably within a professional services environment

* Bachelor’s degree preferred