← Search all jobs

Personal Lines Account Manager

Harrison Gray Search & Consulting

Wisconsin, United States · Posted November 11, 2026

Just laid off? Start here: a plan for the first weeks

See every open role at Harrison Gray Search & Consulting

More in Wisconsin job market · Financial Services & Banking · Sales jobs

More roles at Harrison Gray Search & Consulting

Similar jobs

Sales jobs in the rankings

Rankings about sales jobs

Sales jobs · Top Sales employers · All rankings

How AI is used in this kind of work

Among insurance sales agents, AI is already used for a large share of the tasks. Measured exposure for insurance sales agents: 32% (high).

Share of this job’s tasks that AI is already used for at work, from real usage. It is not a forecast of job loss, and a low number means no use seen yet. Source: Anthropic Economic Index.

Check how this applies to your own job

About the job

Personal Lines Account Manager

Wisconsin | Full-Time

About the Opportunity

Harrison Gray Search has partnered with a well-established independent insurance agency to identify a detail-oriented Personal Lines Account Manager to join its team in Wisconsin.

This role is ideal for a customer-focused insurance professional who enjoys helping clients, managing policy service requests, and keeping day-to-day operations running smoothly. You will support the personal lines department by assisting with policy changes, renewals, certificates, and other service-related needs while delivering a positive experience for clients.

This is an in-office opportunity at one of the agency's Wisconsin office locations, offering the chance to join a respected organization with a collaborative team environment and opportunities for professional growth.

If you have a background in personal lines insurance, strong organizational skills, and a commitment to exceptional customer service, this could be a great opportunity to take the next step in your insurance career.

Job Details

Job Title: Personal Lines Account Manager

Job Type: Full-Time

Location: Wisconsin (In-Office at One of the Agency's Office Locations)

Schedule: Monday–Friday

Key Responsibilities

Personal Lines Policy Service

Process policy changes, endorsements, cancellations, and other service requests.

Assist with new business applications, policy renewals, and related documentation.

Prepare insurance certificates, policy documents, and other client materials as needed.

Review policy information for accuracy and ensure records are properly maintained in the agency management system.

Follow up on outstanding requests and documentation to ensure timely completion.

Client Support & Communication

Respond to client questions regarding personal insurance policies, coverage details, and service needs.

Provide prompt, professional assistance and help resolve routine policy-related issues.

Communicate with insurance carriers to obtain information, process requests, and address policy concerns.

Build positive client relationships through reliable follow-up and attentive service.

Administrative & Team Support

Maintain accurate client files, policy records, and electronic documentation.

Manage multiple service requests while meeting established deadlines.

Collaborate with account managers, agents, and other team members to support efficient department operations.

Assist with general administrative duties and additional service tasks as needed.

Requirements & Qualifications

Previous experience in personal lines insurance.

Familiarity with personal insurance products, including homeowners, auto, renters, and umbrella policies.

Strong verbal and written communication skills.

Excellent attention to detail and organizational skills.

Ability to manage multiple priorities and follow through on outstanding tasks.

Comfortable using computers, electronic documentation, and agency management systems.

A customer-first mindset and the ability to work independently and collaboratively.

License Requirements

An active Wisconsin Property & Casualty insurance license is preferred, or the ability to obtain one as required.

Benefits & Perks

Health, dental, and vision insurance.

Retirement plan.

Life and disability insurance.

Paid time off (PTO).

Parental leave.

Hands-on training and professional development opportunities.

Consistent weekday schedule.

About the Agency

Our client is one of Wisconsin's largest and most respected independent insurance agencies, providing personal insurance, commercial insurance, and employee benefits solutions. With 19 locations throughout the state, the agency has built a strong reputation for client advocacy, long-term relationships, and a commitment to delivering quality service.

The team values hard work, collaboration, and professional growth, offering employees the opportunity to build their insurance careers within an established and supportive organization.